Measure for Measure: No Harsh Judgements for the Funny Fallible Human

Jonathan Cake. All photos by Gerry Goodstein.

Measure for Measure: No Harsh Judgements for the Funny Fallible Human

By Ross

I feel blessed sometimes, when the summer in New York supplies us with so much great Shakespeare, and especially this particular summer. I am getting the opportunity to see two of his plays that I have never seen nor read before, and that feels like such a great gift. Shakespeare in the Park’s Julius Caesar is a gift from The Public Theatre, much to the discontent of the Far Right (even though their cause sits on a false narrative: click here to read my review), and now Theatre for a New Audience has bestowed upon us a rowdy and rambunctious Measure for Measure, a play that I have heard of, but never have had the opportunity to see. And what a festive treat TFANA has given us here in Brooklyn.

January Lavoy, Christopher Michael McFarland.
The design team, made up of scenic and costume designer, Paul Wills (West End’s Mrs. Henderson Presents), and lighting by Matthew Richards (Westside Arts’ Absolute Brightness…), has crafted a not so subtle decent into an immoral world where clashing arguments about our humanity and power reside. As we enter the theatre, we are fed through a labyrinth of dildo-strewn hallways and erotic scenarios set up for our amusement. Are we supposed to be shocked or titillated by these suggestive scenarios we encounter in Mistress Overdone’s brothel hallways?  This question resonates throughout much of Shakespeare’s Measure for Measure directed by the inventive Simon Godwin (NT’s gender-fluid Twelfth Night) especially during the first scene. Duke Vincento seems to be falling down a rabbit hole of debauchery and addiction. He decides quite suddenly it seems, to transfer his judicial power over to the high minded and puritanical Angelo (Thomas Jan Ryan) and his assistant, Escala (January Lavoy), to watch over his Viennese kingdom. The reasonings of the Duke seemed quite unclear though, at least to me. He states he is leaving Angelo in charge so he may clamp down on Vienna’s rampant vice that has grown under the Duke’s watch, yet he remains in disguise to watch over what transpires in his absence. I’m not quite sure I trust his logistical and moral arguments he makes throughout. The Duke, as played with great humor and charm by Jonathan Cake (TFANA’s Much Ado About Nothing) is quite the mischievous soul, toying with people’s emotional state as if it’s all a big morality game. He has his reasons for each deception, or so he says, but for this spectator, he left me feeling suspicious and cool to his ways and means. What are we to make of the Duke? He’s like the practical jokester that sometimes goes too far with his charade manipulating and correcting others while his personal participation and power to intercede is left unquestioned.

Jonathan Cake, Leland Fowler.
This play, first performed in 1604, explores the complex balance between justice, mercy, and virtue.  The wondrous Lavoy (Wakey Wakey) as his dutiful and thoughtful assistant, Escala (also playing triple duty, almost unrecognizable in the parts of Mistress Overdone and Francisca) has an understanding of mercy and forgiveness that few have in this strange and incongruent play. It is she who states, quite elegantly that “some rise by sin, and some by virtue fall”, and in this we have the essence of what’s at stake. Angelo, played with a snake-like oiliness by Ryan (The Crucible) is by no means a true villain but only a man repressed and unhinged by a sexual awakening caused by the angelic sight of Isabella, played effectively with wit and grace by Canadian Cara Ricketts (Stratford Festival’s Cymbeline). She has come to Angelo to plead for the life of her brother, Claudio (Leland Fowler) whom Angelo has decided to make an example of, charging him with a long disused law that punishes sexual activity outside of marriage with death.  In a timely parallel to modern politics, Angelo going against all that he publicly stands for, stricken with an immoral desire for Isabella, proposes a Faustian deal. He will spare her brother’s life if Isabella will give up her virtue and sleep with him. It brings to mind so many politicians and religious zealots who condemn others for indecent acts, that, as it turns out, they are committing themselves. Hypocrisy is alive and well in M4M’s Vienna and modern day American politics. 

Thomas Jay Ryan, Cara Ricketts.
Filling out this wild play are numerous moments of comedic brilliance. One such master, Zachary Fine (The Pearl’s Vanity Fair) as the topsy-turvy Constable Elbow, makes the ridiculous even more so, messing with the biased righteousness of the law by turning it on its head. So does the dead man walking-to-be, Barnardine, also thrilling portrayed by Fine. His rational defense against dying, refusing to cooperate in a beheading  on the day it is needed is dastardly funny and compelling all at the same time. He messes with just one of the many convoluted plots hatched by the disguised Duke, and for what, we are never quite sure. 

Zachary Fine.
The only character that got under my skin, as he did with the duplicitous Duke, is the never quiet nor truthful Lucio, played up to the edge of frustration by Haynes Thigpen (Roundabout Underground’s Ugly Lies The Bone.  It’s either a stellar and purposefully winning portrayal or an annoying one, but this maybe the genius of Shakespeare, as we are never quite sure. His writing of this play is engaging, more straightforward, and to the point then most, even in his more well crafted dark comedies. I’m in love with the poetry of Shakespeare, but this play just seemed more accessible. The music, performed by the magnificent band (Drew Bastian, Robert Cowie, Osei Essed) is just as engaging and unique, adding soul to the flavor and the festivities (Composer and Sound Design: Jane Shaw).

Zachary Fine, Christopher Michael McFarland.

The play and this provocative production quite readily brings to mind our own highly polarized world where religion and law are too wrapped up together without a shred of reason or mercy. Shakespeare seems to want to say that the law, without forgiveness and thoughtful mercy is too harsh and uncaring. Marianna, spectacularly played by Merritt Janson (Red Bull’s Coriolanus) while wronged by so many, sings her way into our hearts from the first moments in Act II, and is the one to beg for the life of the man who of all the characters in Measure for Measure, deserve his punishment. She asks for forgiveness from Isabella and leniency from the Duke, stating that we all are fallible and need mercy and kindness over harsh judgments. It’s a touching ending for a beautifully crafted production of a complex and problematic play. Repression, lust, hypocrisy, and disturbing sexual politics has never been so much fun or more wildly brought forth.

Cara Ricketts, Leland Fowler.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s