“Benjamin Button” Finds His Glorious Rhythm in the Turning Tide

The cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at The Public Theater. Photo by Joan Marcus.

The Off-Broadway Theatre Review: The Public’s imaginative actor-musician ensemble brings a curious tale of time and love to life.

By Ross

Foghorns blast their warnings and flashlights cut through the darkness as the rhythm of the ocean swirls around us at The Public Theater, where The Curious Case of Benjamin Button has sailed into the Newman Theater with its wonderfully distinctive musical spirit. I have a particular fondness for the way this production draws us into its world, allowing the sounds of the sea and the melodies of its musicians to do the welcoming. “It’s often said…” is the opening line, and off we go, like hungry fish taking the bait, ready to follow a curious tale in which time behaves rather differently on one particular day in 1918. Set in a Cornish fishing village, this is a story that knows how to cast its spell, with a little Celtic magic, a generous helping of musical charm, and a life that will unfold in reverse.

One by one, the villagers emerge as a man makes his way into town, eager to meet the child his wife is about to deliver. What awaits him is a newborn son who appears to be an elderly gentleman, complete with a three-piece suit, cane, and smoking pipe. “And then precisely on time, it all goes backward.” The newly made mother, Mary Button, played by Sachiko Mae, and father, Roger Button, played by Brandon J. Ellis, find themselves confronting a child they cannot quite bring themselves to accept. Their decision to keep Benjamin hidden away in the attic is a cruel beginning for a life that has barely begun, with shame and bewilderment shaping the first chapter of his peculiar existence. All Benjamin wants is a little life of his own, and Andrew Durand gives him an abundance of it, bringing an open-hearted curiosity and an appealing innocence to the title role. Having spent more than half of his time onstage as the motionless Dead Outlaw on Broadway, Durand now gets to stretch his legs, quite literally, as Benjamin gradually ages into his youth, his energy and curiosity expanding with every backward turn of the clock.

Andrew Durand, Kelsee Kimmel, and the cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at The Public Theater. Photo by Joan Marcus.

Once Benjamin has aged backwards enough to climb out of that little attic window, he takes his life into his own hands, old as they may be, and sets off into the world. His mother Mary has already taken her own final plunge into the sea, and Benjamin’s escape opens the door to a life filled with encounters, unexpected turns, and a whole village of people whose paths become entwined with his. “And so begins the next chapter” is a lovely invitation into the adventure, which unfolds with the flavour of a Cornish folk story, carried along by Darren Clark’s beautifully melodic score. The musicality is astonishing, with the actors taking on multiple roles while playing an assortment of instruments, creating a fluid theatrical landscape in which music, movement, and storytelling seem to spring from the same source. Under Jethro Compton’s direction and choreography by Chi-San Howard, the ensemble moves with a wonderfully instinctive unity, making the whole enterprise feel alive with the energy of a community telling its own story.

At the heart of this wonderfully resourceful company are Durand’s Benjamin and Kelsee Kimmel as Elowen Keene, surrounded by performers who bring a remarkable range of characters and musical textures into the life of the village. Kimmel gives Elowen a lovely warmth and spirit, with a presence that draws Benjamin toward the possibility of love and belonging. Their connection gives the story its emotional centre, bringing a tenderness and recognizably human dimension to the extraordinary circumstances of Benjamin’s life. Kimmel’s line, “This is a thought,” becomes an invitation to follow the imagination wherever it might lead, although I would add that it is also a fact, so pour me another and let’s not resist. Morgan Morse brings an especially endearing quality to Jack Trenlee, Benjamin’s young companion and devoted friend. There is a lovely poignancy in his later inability to believe that the young man standing before him could possibly be the older friend he once knew and loved. Morse gives that moment a touching mixture of affection, confusion, and loss. Around them, Britney Coleman, Katie Horner, Kris Saint-Louis, Claire-Frances Sullivan, Trevor Lindley Craft, Matt Wolpe, and the rest of this fifteen-member company create a richly populated world. The performers move between roles and musical contributions with such assurance that the village seems to keep breathing and changing right before our eyes.

Andrew Durand, Morgan Morse, and the cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at The Public Theater. Photo by Joan Marcus.

Jethro Compton‘s scenic design gives the production its evocative coastal world, while Anna Kelsey’s costumes help the characters inhabit their many identities and the particular period atmosphere of the story. Zoe Spurr‘s lighting is especially effective in shaping the mystery of the sea and the darkness surrounding Benjamin’s journey, with Luke Swaffield’s sound design giving the fog bells, ocean, and musical world an enveloping presence. There are glorious theatrical moments, including the flashlight-lit message in a bottle and Benjamin’s two encounters with the ocean, when he seems ready to surrender to the call of death. Each time, the water holds its own mystery, and life has another chapter waiting for him. The image of Benjamin floating there, suspended between what he believes is an ending and what may still lie ahead, is beautifully realized. The music and movement lend these moments a dreamlike quality, allowing the story to drift into the mysterious territory of fable.

A particular chain of events is set in motion, and then set in motion again, as time and happenstance carry Benjamin along a winding path through love, loss, and the changing fortunes of the people around him. Based on F. Scott Fitzgerald’s short story, this musical adaptation by writer and director Jethro Compton and Darren Clark gives the story a strong narrative current, while Mark Aspinall’s musical direction, orchestrations, and arrangements keep the many instruments and voices flowing together with remarkable precision. The performers move between character, song, and instrument with such ease that the production seems to have a magnificent pulse of its own. There is an infectious pleasure in watching the company create this world before our eyes, the melodies carrying the story forward and backward, sometimes with a lilting Celtic charm that makes it awfully tempting to sit back, listen, and let the tide take us along.

The cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at The Public Theater. Photo by Joan Marcus.

When I was finally washed ashore at the Newman Theater, I found myself carrying the same affection for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button that had accompanied me from its West End run. Its arrival at The Public Theater gives this remarkable company a lovely opportunity to share Benjamin’s story with New York audiences.. Durand brings a generous humanity to a man whose life unfolds in a direction all its own, while Kimmel gives him a connection that makes the journey feel deeply worth taking. The production is full of musical invention, theatrical imagination, and a company whose collective talents create something genuinely captivating. Yet its emotional heart is beautifully simple. Benjamin wants to live, to love, to find his place in the world, and to be welcomed into the lives of those around him. The sea calls to him twice, and twice he finds himself carried back toward the life still waiting. With fog bells sounding and the tide turning, this curious story has found its way into my heart, and I was more than happy to let it carry me along.

Kelsee Kimmel, Andrew Durand, and the cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button at The Public Theater. Photo by Joan Marcus. For more information and tickets, click here.

Leave a Reply